New England Lighthouses: A Virtual Guide

White Island Light (Isles of Shoals Light)

Rye, New Hampshire

White Island Light main page / History / Bibliography / Cruises / Photos / Postcards


History
© Jeremy D'Entremont. Do not reproduce any part of this website without permission of the author.

The Isles of Shoals, a cluster of nine islands located several miles off the seacoast of New Hampshire, were described by Robert Thayer Sterling in Maine Lighthouses and the Men Who Keep Them as "a low lying group apparently composed of masses of tumbled granite bleached white by the unceasing beating of the storm king and the glare of the blazing sun."

The islands were frequented by European fishermen for years before Capt. John Smith explored them in 1614. Smith named the islands "Smith's Isles" after himself.

According to some accounts, fishermen named the islands after their resemblance to a school, or shoal, of fish. Others say the name originated beacuse of the "shoaling," or schooling, of fish, especially mackerel and herring, around them.


#

The area remained an important fishing center for centuries. The first lighthouse in the Isles of Shoals was established on White Island in 1821. It was a stone tower, later encased with wood and shingled.

The lighthouse's original characteristic was unusually patriotic, with red, white, and blue flashes. The blue flash was soon discontinued because of its poor visibility.


I received the following message from Joe Kenick Jr. in July 2011:

My now 101-year-old Mom has taught us that a White Island light keeper in the 1830s was William Randall.  His wife, Eliza G. Randall, died there at age 40 in September 1836 leaving him with a very young baby.  I'm told he rowed her body over to Star and wrote in his journal, "There isn't enough dirt on White Island to bury a mackerel."  She is buried next to one of the young Caswell women and has head and foot stones that match several of the Caswell ones.

Mr. Randall turned his infant son over to his (or Eliza's, I'm vague on this) sister who was married into the Waldron family. That baby, known as Benjamin Franklin Waldron became the father of Mina Waldron Frost Fifield, who became the mother of my Mom, Pualine Fifield Kenick.

Whenever I visit the Shoals I visit her grave, bring flowers and pray there.  

In 1838, this was nearly one of the first American lighthouses to have a Fresnel lens installed, but it was decided that the tower was too low for a satisfactory test of the lens. A new lantern and lighting apparatus were installed in 1841.

During the following year, engineer I.W.P. Lewis inspected the station and reported, "The whole construction of the apparatus bears the mark of rude workmanship." The lamps and reflectors weren't replaced by a more efficient Fresnel lens until 1855.

In 1839, Thomas Laighton (1805-1866) became keeper. He and his brother Joseph had bought three of the islands in the Isles of Shoals including the largest, Hog (later known as Appledore), and Smuttynose.

old photo of lighthouse

The first White Island Lighthouse, circa late 1850s
U.S. Coast Guard photo

Thomas Laighton was a former postmaster and representative to the New Hampshire legislature, and he had recently lost a run for selectman in Portsmouth. Laighton and his wife, Eliza, moved to White Island with their two children, Oscar and Celia. In 1841 a baby, Cedric, was born to the Laightons at the lighthouse.

Laighton's daughter, Celia, later gained widespread fame as Celia Thaxter, poet and author.

In her book, Among the Isles of Shoals, she described the family's arrival at White Island:

It was at sunset in autumn that we were set ashore on that loneliest, lovely rock, where the lighthouse looked down on us like some tall, black-capped giant, and filled me with awe and wonder. At its base a few goats were grouped on the rock, standing out against the red sky as I looked up at them...

Some one began to light the lamps in the tower. Rich red and golden, they swung around in mid-air; everything was strange and fascinating and new.

Celia Thaxter

Celia (Laighton) Thaxter

She wrote about an evening visit to the water's edge:

High above, the lighthouse rays streamed out into the humid dark, and the cottage windows were ruddy from the glow within. I felt so much a part of the Lord's universe, I was no more afraid of the dark than the wave or the winds.

Storms frequently swept over White Island. One particularly severe gale struck in 1839 when Celia was four years old, washing away henhouses and forcing her father to bring the family's cow into the kitchen. During the storm the brig Pocahontas was wrecked on a nearby sandbar and all aboard perished. The memory of this incident inspired Celia Thaxter's poem, "The Wreck of the Pocahontas," which read, in part:

 
 I lit the lamps in the lighthouse tower,
For the sun dropped down and the day was dead.
They shone like a glorious clustered flower,
Ten golden and five red.
 
Like all the demons loosed at last,
Whistling and shrieking, wild and wide,
The mad wind raged, while strong and fast
Rolled in the rising tide.
 
The thick storm seemed to break apart
To show us, staggering to her grave,
The fated brig. We had no heart
To look, for naught could save.
 

Many visitors came to White Island in the summers while the Laightons lived there. The visitors included Richard Henry Dana, author of Two Years Before the Mast.

In times of rough weather, the residents of White Island were frequently cut off from the mainland. A pilot boat brought mail and supplies every week or ten days. Once a year Eliza Laighton traveled to Portsmouth to buy materials to make clothing for her family. A few times a year the lighthouse inspector would come, bringing oil for the lamps and other supplies, sometimes including a barrel of pork.

Celia's brother, Oscar Laighton, wrote about his childhood on White Island in his book, Ninety Years at the Isles of Shoals:

Many people have said, 'You must have been very lonely at the Light.' They did not know that where our mother dwelt there was happiness also. I am sure no family was ever more united and contented than the Laightons on White Island.

As a young girl, Celia learned to help her father light the lamps and polish the reflectors and lantern glass. The Laightons eventually moved to the much larger island of Appledore, where they operated a hotel for many years. The hotel's guests included Longfellow, Emerson, and Whittier. Levi Thaxter tutored the Laighton children; he and Celia eventually married.

The author Nathaniel Hawthorne visited White Island with Celia Thaxter's husband, Levi Thaxter, on September 9, 1852. The keeper at the time was L. H. D. Shepard. Hawthorne's description of the visit appears in his American Note-Books:

Mr. Thaxter rowed me this morning, in his dory, to White Island, on which is the lighthouse. There was scarcely a breath of air, and a perfectly calm sea; an intensely hot sunshine, with a little haze, so that the horizon was indistinct. Here and there sail-boats sleeping on the water, or moving almost imperceptibly over it. The lighthouse island would be difficult of access in a rough sea, the shore being so rocky. On landing, we found the keeper peeling his harvest of onions, which he had gathered prematurely, because the insects were eating them. His little patch of garden seemed to be a strange kind of soil, as like marine mud as anything; but he had a fair crop of marrow squashes, though injured, as he said, by the last storm; and there were cabbages and a few turnips. I recollect no other garden vegetables. The grass grows pretty luxuriantly, and looked very green where there was any soil; but he kept no cow, nor even a pig nor a hen. His house stands close by the garden,--a small stone building, with peaked roof, and whitewashed. The lighthouse stands on a ledge of rock, with a gulley between, and there is a long covered way, triangular in shape, connecting his residence with it. We ascended into the lantern, which is eighty-seven feet high. It is a revolving light, with several great illuminators of copper silvered, and colored lamp-glasses. Looking downward, we had the island displayed as on a chart, with its little bays, its isthmus of shingly beach connecting two parts of the island, and overflowed at high tide; its sunken rocks about it, indicated by the swell, or slightly breaking surf. The keeper of the light-house was formerly a writing-master. He has a sneaking kind of look, and does not bear a very high character among his neighbors. Since he kept the light, he has lost two wives--the first a young creature whom he used to leave alone upon this desolate rock, and the gloom and terror of the situation were probably the cause of her death.

The second wife, experiencing the same kind of treatment, ran away from him, and returned to her friends. He pretends to be religious, but drinks. About a year ago he attempted to row out alone from Portsmouth. There was a head wind and head tide, and he would have inevitably drifted out to sea, if Mr. Thaxter had not saved him.

While we were standing in his garden-patch, I heard a woman's voice inside the dwelling, but know not whose it was. 
old engraving

A new 58-foot brick lighthouse tower was built on White Island in 1859. The new tower was fitted with a second-order Fresnel lens.

A duplex keeper's house built in 1878 was removed by the Coast Guard in the 1950s.

There was an amazing rescue one winter in the mid-1800s at White Island Light.

John Bragg Downs was temporarily acting as keeper, with a friend as his assistant. The two men were at the lighthouse when a severe blizzard hit, with blinding snow and heavy seas covering the island. One night, much to their shock, there was a knock at the door.


White Island Light c. 1870s

When they opened the door, the men discovered a lone sailor, dressed in tattered rags and bleeding from many wounds. The man had somehow come ashore from a brig wrecked on the rocks.

After a great deal of effort, Downs ventured out on a ledge and managed to get a line to the rest of the crew on the vessel. He then tied the line around himself. Downs wedged himself into a crevice, and every man managed to get ashore from the sinking ship.


The lighthouse station's kitchen, circa 1950.
From The Shoreliner, September 1950.

Right: 1930 Notice to Mariners concerning a chnage in the light characteristic.
1930 notice to mariners about change in light
Douglas Larrabee

Douglas Larrabee was the officer in charge in the early 1950s
Two men standing by lens

Coast Guard keepers John Parks and Bill Cannon in 1950

The fog bell at White Island was replaced by a new bell and striking machinery in 1906. This was replaced later by a powerful air siren.

After the Coast Guard took over at White Island, three men were assigned to the station. Harold Roberts was one of the crewmen in 1956-58. He later wrote the following:

During the winter of 1956, we were experiencing one of those rare days at the Isles of Shoals when the sun was shining and the sea was placid, but it was still bitter cold. I decided to take the small double ended peapod dinghy we used to get on and off the island and row around to the back of the island get close to the seals that often lay on the rocks sunning themselves on such days. This day there was a larger number of seals lying on the rocks and I hoped I could get close to them with arousing them.


U.S. Coast Guard photo

As I rowed around the back side of the island about 200 yards out I suddenly heard a roaring noise to my right. A huge wave, a groundswell about 20 feet high, was coming right at me. I swung the bow of the boat into the wave but not fast enough to prevent the boat from being overturned and me being dumped into the ocean.

The water was bitter cold and I was clothed with heavy foul weather gear including heavy robber boots. The weight of my boots filling with water pulled me down and prevented me from using my legs to kick myself to the surface. Judging from the pressure in my ears I must have sank at least 15 feet before I started slowly rising to the surface. The air trapped in my jacket saved me from being pulled down to the bottom. As soon as I broke surface I started to sink again.  My hands were so frozen I could not unclasp the boots that were preventing me from swimming. I knew I was in grave danger of drowning. In desperation and fear called out to God to save me. A moment later, the capsized dingy suddenly appeared right next to me. I was able to hold on to the boat to stay afloat. My next and most immediate problem was the cold. I was freezing to death. I was aware that a man can't stay alive very long exposed to those conditions. The other problem was I was several hundred yards off the island and no one knew I was in trouble. Charlie Martian and I were alone on the island and he was unaware of my predicament.

I must have fallen asleep from the cold and was not aware that the boat with me clinging half conscious to the side had drifted to the island and a gentle swell pushed us into the rocks. I had enough strength to climb up out of the water and make my way to the keeper’s house. Charley Martian was in the kitchen when I came in the door. I must looked frozen which I was. Charlie got blankets for me to help me recover my body heat.

To this day I believe it was divine intervention that saved my life on that bitter cold winter day on the Isles of Shoals.

Kevin Murphy was one of the Coast Guard keepers 1982-83. In an email in August 2009, he wrote, "While I have no horrific storm stories to tell, we certainly had our share of storms and there where times we would get stuck out on the island for a month because we couldn’t get the dory off the island. Occasionally we had to be air lifted off the island which I thought was kind of fun!" 


Murphy says he enjoyed his time on the island and he's happy to see that local people are working for the preservation of the light station's buildings.

Glenn Young of York, Maine, was a machinery technician when he was in the Coast Guard. He was stationed on the island during a memorable storm in March 1984. As 35-foot waves crashed against the lighthouse and keeper's house, the crewmen calmly watched TV.

About once an hour, Young went to check the light. To do so he had to go through an enclosed wooden walkway between the house and tower. Waves were washing right over the walkway and water was pouring through the cracks, so Young had to wait for the waves to recede before running the length of the walkway. The storm did much damage at the station and deposited a 3 1/2-ton boulder on the helicopter pad.

Boat ramp an dpeapod boat circa 1950s

The boat ramp and peapod boat in the 1950s
Rick Bennett and Kevin Madison were among the last Coast Guardsmen at White Island. In the summer, the men would visit the inhabitants of the other islands nearby. Storms sometimes made it very difficult for the crew to land at White Island.

Kevin Madison says that although the 1986 automation of White Island Light was sad in a way, it was also very interesting. The Coast Guard crew spent three months working with a civilian crew from Portland on the automation process.

After the automation, the Coast Guard keepers were removed. A couple of years later, the huge Fresnel lens was replaced by aerobeacons. The present VRB-25 optic is solar-powered.

Hurricane Bob and the ferocious "Perfect Storm" of October 1991 washed away the walkway from the tower to the house, as well as the old fog signal tower.


This video was shot by one of the Coast Guard lighthouse keepers during the blizzard of February 6-7, 1978. It was probably shot from the keeper's house. You can see a storage shed being moved around by the waves that are reaching far up onto the island. Courtesy of Sue Reynolds, The Lighthouse Kids.

people with birds all around
Members of the Audubon Society of New Hampshire conducting a tern count on Seavey Island

In 1993, White Island became the property of the State of New Hampshire. The keeper's house has been used in recent years by personnel of the Audubon Society of New Hampshire, who have implemented a tern restoration project on adjacent Seavey Island.

Over the years, the lighthouse tower developed major cracks in its exterior, mostly on the northeast side that bears the brunt of storms.

The good news is that seventh grade students in North Hampton, New Hampshire, along with a teacher, Sue Reynolds, have worked to save the lighthouse. You can see the website of the "Lighthouse Kids" here.

On April 30, 2003, Senator Judd Gregg of New Hampshire announced that a matching grant of $250,000 in federal funds from the Save America's Treasures program was awarded for the restoration of the White Island Lighthouse.

On June 22, 2005, the Lighthouse Kids presented New Hampshire Governor John Lynch with a check for $110,000. In accepting the check, the state authorized the Division of Parks and Recreation to expend the money for conservation and restoration of the White Island Light Station.

cracks
Some of the cracks on the tower's exterior in 2002
Lighthouse Kids

Some of the "Lighthouse Kids" on a trip to White Island, June 20, 2002
The check represented money the Lighthouse Kids raised through corporate and private fundraising, foundation grants and merchandise sales. It was combined with a portion of the $250,000 Save America's Treasures grant and state funds to allow a full restoration of the tower and a partial restoration of the keeper's house.

The work was done during the summer of 2005 by Ricci Construction of Portsmouth, NH, J. B. Leslie Company of South Berwick, Maine, and F. A. Gray Company of Portsmouth.
kids neasuring

The Lighthouse Kids measured the cracks in the lighthouse on October 10, 2002

Local businesses pitched in to help the Kids

The Lighthouse Kids in downtown Portsmouth, NH, April 8, 2005

The keeper's house was reroofed and painted, and rotting woodwork was replaced. The renovations stopped water leaks that had plagued the house in recent years.

More than 1,000 bricks were replaced in the tower during the 2005 restoration. The brick courses were strengthened with the addition of stainless steel ties, and the entire tower received a protective layer of stucco. The glass block windows in the tower were replaced by windows that are more like the original ones.

A northeast storm in mid-April 2007 did much damage on the island. The walkway was demolished, and the solar panels for the light were swept away.

In early 2008, the rotating VRB-25 optic that had been in use at White Island for several years was replaced by a solar-powered VLB-44 light emitting diode unit (LED).

The walkway between the tower and house was rebuilt using FEMA funds in the summer of 2011.


An aerial view of Star Island with White Island in the background.
 

The lighthouse in June 2007, after the covered walkway was demolished by a storm in April

 photo of lighthouse with walkway under construction

The walkway between the tower and house was being reconstructed when this photo was taken in September 2011.



Keepers: 

(This list is a work in progress. If you have any information on the keepers of this lighthouse, I'd love to hear from you. You can email me at nelights@gmail.com. Anyone copying this list onto another web site does so at their own risk, as the list is always subject to updates and corrections.)

William Randall (c. 1830s?); Joseph L. Locke (c.1831-1839); Thomas Laighton (1839-1846); Ben Whaling (employee of Thomas Laighton, c.1839-1846); Fabius Becker (c.1846-1849?); L. H. D. Shepard (1849-1855); Richard G. Haley (1855-1861); Otis F. Haley (assistant, 1859-1861); John Bragg Downs (c. 1850, temporary keeper); Alfred J. Leavitt (1861-1866); Jonathan Godfrey (assistant, 1861-1863); Alonzo D. Berry (assistant, 1863-1864); Albert S. Perkins (assistant, 1864-1866); John E. Hoyt (assistant, 1866-1867); Alonzo Wise (1866-1869); George Balch (assistant, 1867-1868); John L. Allen (assistant, 1867-1868); Wiliam H. White (assistant, 1868-1869); Frank A. Otis (assistant, 1868-1870); Joshua Bickford (1869); Jonathan W. Berry (1869-1874); Abram Mathes (?) (assistant, 1869-1871); Thomas J. Varrell (assistant, 1870); George Chaplin (assistant, 1871); ? Gray (assistant, 1870); ? A. Yeaton (assistant, 1872); Parsons (?) Locke (assistant, 1872-1873); Charles H. Ramsdell (second assistant, 1873); Franklin R. Bragden (assistant, 1874-1876); Israel P. Miller (1874-1876); Edwin J. Hobbs (1876-1880); Alden W. P. White (assistant, 1876-1877, 1880); David R. Grogan (1880-1894); James Burke (1894-1912); Elias Tarlton, Jr. (assistant, 1884-1890); Thomas H. Barber (assistant, 1890-1891); Walter S. Amee (assistant, 1893); John Scannell (assistant, 1893-1894); John A. Hall (assistant, 1894-1896); Wallace S. Chase (assistant, 1897); William M. Brooks (assistant, 1897); Gordon A. Sullivan (assistant, 1909-1912); Alvah Robinson (assistant, c. 1914?); Edwin A. Pettegrow (c. early 1920s); Albert Staples (1926-1930); Charles U. Gardner (Coast Guard relief keeper, c, 1942-1943) ; Douglas Larrabee (c. 1950); Bill Cannon (Coast Guard, c. 1948-1950); John Parks (Coast Guard, c, 1948-1950); Charles Martin (c. 1956-1958); Harold Roberts (c. 1956-1958); Anthony Cherico (c. 1956-1958); Allan Petersen (USCG Officer in Charge, 1961-1962); BM1 Ira Machon (Coast Guard Officer in Charge, c. 1965-1966); ? Gordon, USCG (1968-1970); Bruce Blanchard (Coast Guard EN2, 1968-70); Bob Larson (Coast Guard, 1972-1974); Ron Tinkham (Coast Guard, 1972-1974); John C. Waterman (Coast Guard, c. 1977-1978); PO1 Rick Loster, USCG Officer in Charge (8/1983-6/1984); FN Kevin Murphy (Coast Guard, 1982-1983); PO3 Joel Wood (Coast Guard, c. 1983);  Jeff Jones, (Coast Guard, c. 1983); Scott Powell, (Coast Guard, c. 1983); Glenn Young (Coast Guard, c. 1984); Rick Bennett, (Coast Guard, c. 1986); Kevin Madison, (Coast Guard, c. 1986)

Last updated 12/29/11

© Jeremy D'Entremont. Do not reproduce any part of this website without permission of the author.

Unless otherwise specified, the historic images on this page are from the collection of
Edward Rowe Snow and are used with the permssion of Dorothy Bicknell

White Island Light main page / History / Bibliography / Cruises / Photos / Postcards

New Hampshire Menu / New England Menu / Back to Contents

Save up to 40% on Last Minute Flights with Hotwire Limited Rates!
 

Vote for this site on Top 25 Lighthouse Web Sites List!

lighthouse banner