In 1609, Samuel de Champlain landed at Isle la Motte on Lake Champlain, close to the border with Quebec. The island became the site of the first French settlement in Vermont in 1666. The Shrine of Ste. Anne stands today where the French under Captain Sieur de La Motte built Fort Ste. Anne in 1666.  The island was attacked by British gunboats in the War of 1812. The Battle of Plattsburgh ensued, a major American victory and the largest battle ever on Lake Champlain.

Lake Champlain, bordering New York, Vermont and Quebec, was once a bustling waterway. The opening of the Champlain Canal in 1823 meant faster shipping to New York, and navigational aids were needed.  There were many private aids to navigation placed by the shipping companies, but the U.S. Government eventually realized permanent aids were needed. More than ten lighthouses were built on the lake in the 19th century, on both the New York and Vermont sides. A light was established at Isle La Motte about 1829. This light was actually a lantern placed in an upper window of a stone house belonging to Ezra Pike, Jr. The house, seen at left, still stands and is a private residence.

In 1856, the federal. government paid $50 for a lot of land previously belonging to John D. Reynolds and John R. McGregor. A stone pyramid with a lantern was erected. John D. Reynolds, who was a Civil War veteran, served as the first keeper. There was no house near the beacon, so Reynolds had to travel a good distance to tend the light. Increased shipping traffic in the area made a more permanent lighthouse a necessity. In 1879, Congress appropriated $5,000 for a "better light" and a keeper's house.

Meanwhile, John D. Reynolds had died. His son, Elisha R. Reynolds, believed that he had inherited the property and was quite surprised when workmen arrived and started building the lighthouse keeper's dwelling. Reynolds made a claim for compensation, but it was dismissed when the deed was produced showing that his father had sold the land to the government.

The present 25-foot cast iron lighthouse was built in 1880 along with the wooden keeper's dwelling. The tower, equipped with a sixth order Fresnel lens, displayed a fixed white light. This light was 46 feet above water and its light was visible for 13 miles.

Wilbur F. Hill was keeper of the old beacon starting in 1871, and he remained at the new lighthouse station until 1919, serving 48 years as keeper. During his years at Isle la Motte Light, Keeper Hill received awards for having the best kept station in the district.  Hill also maintained a 100-acre farm nearby. Wilbur Hill retired from lighthouse keeping about six weeks before he died. The station's final keeper was William Grant, the nephew of Maine lighthouse heroine Abbie Burgess Grant.

Lucky Clark made this sign that includes a replica of the lighthouse

Isle La Motte Lighthouse on the day of relighting, October 5, 2002 Photo by Sue LeFever

On the evening of October 5, 2002, the Isle la Motte Lighthouse returned to service at dusk. Attendance at the relighting ceremony was estimated at more than 300. As the moment of relighting approached, everyone counted down from ten. Local schoolchildren had the honor of relighting the lighthouse. The group included Lois Cameron, great-granddaughter of Keeper Wilbur Hill. As the light came on at 6:18 p.m., a cannon blazed and Lucky Clark vigorously rang the bell near the lighthouse. The light station is a private residence and is closed to the public. The lighthouse, painted orange some years ago, has faded to a pinkish rose color, or as the locals call it, "Nantucket Red" or "salmon."

Unlike most cast-iron lighthouses, Isle la Motte has no brick lining. Two ladders lead from the base to the lantern room.

A view from the top, encompassing the old skeleton tower.

John D. Reynolds (1857-1862); Ezra Pike, Jr. (1862-1871); Wilbur F. Hill (1871-1919); William Grant (1919-1933)